The 5 Best Subs Around Martinsburg

A great sub isn’t just a sandwich — it’s an art form. From the perfect bread to the right ratio of meats, cheeses, and sauces, Martinsburg’s sub shops have mastered the balance between hearty and handheld. Whether toasted, cold, or piled high with custom toppings, these local favorites deliver serious flavor in every bite. The Best of the Best contest highlighted the region’s go-to spots for subs that hit the spot, one delicious layer at a time.

Jersey Mike’s Subs

Jersey Mike’s Subs in Martinsburg brings East Coast authenticity to every order. Known for its fresh-sliced meats, cheeses, and signature “Mike’s Way” seasoning, this nationally loved chain has built a local following with its consistency and quality. From the classic Italian to the fan-favorite Club Sub, each sandwich is crafted to order on soft, freshly baked bread. Add in a friendly crew and fast service, and it’s no wonder Jersey Mike’s has become a lunchtime staple.

Ganotown Ice Cream

It’s not every day you find a place that serves both scoops and subs, but Ganotown Ice Cream in Hedgesville makes it work beautifully. This cozy local spot surprises first-time visitors with its delicious deli sandwiches — made fresh, stacked high, and served with the same hometown care as their desserts. It’s the perfect place to grab lunch and finish with a sweet treat, all under one roof.

King’s New York Pizza

King’s New York Pizza might be famous for its pies, but locals know their subs are every bit as satisfying. Served on soft Italian rolls and loaded with meats, cheeses, and veggies, these subs deliver a perfect blend of texture and flavor. From meatball parm to turkey and provolone, every sandwich tastes like it was made by someone who knows what comfort food really means.

Food By Fire

Food By Fire in Martinsburg turns up the heat on traditional sandwiches with its wood-fired creations. Their subs are packed with smoky flavor, featuring fresh ingredients grilled or roasted over an open flame. Whether it’s a pulled pork sub dripping with house-made sauce or a Philly-style steak sandwich with a smoky twist, each bite reminds you that a little fire goes a long way.

Tuckers Pucker with Stoner Dogs, Subs, & Sammies

Tuckers Pucker in Hagerstown isn’t your average sub stop — it’s a one-of-a-kind food experience. Known for inventive takes on American classics, this local favorite piles on the flavor with over-the-top combinations and playful names. The subs are as bold as their brand: messy, mouthwatering, and unapologetically satisfying. It’s the kind of place where every sandwich comes with attitude — and plenty of napkins.

Thanks, ChatGPT.