The 5 Best Steaks Around Martinsburg

Whether grilled, seared, or smoked to perfection, a great steak is a celebration of craftsmanship and quality. Martinsburg’s butchers, markets, and restaurants know that flavor starts with the source — and that the right cut can make all the difference. The Best of the Best contest showcased the places that take steak seriously, from old-school meat markets to refined dining rooms where every bite is worth savoring.

Crestview Meat Market

Crestview Meat Market in Martinsburg has earned its reputation as a go-to for premium cuts and old-fashioned service. Known for its selection of locally sourced meats and expert butchering, Crestview offers everything from ribeyes to filets, all cut to order and handled with care. Customers love the personal touch — knowledgeable staff, fair prices, and meat so fresh you can taste the difference. It’s a local landmark where grilling greatness begins.

D&D Meats

For over three decades, D&D Meats in Inwood has been a cornerstone of the community — and a haven for anyone who appreciates quality beef. This family-owned shop specializes in hand-cut steaks, house-made sausages, and custom processing. The team’s dedication to freshness and consistency has made D&D a trusted name among local chefs and backyard grill masters alike. When you want your steak sourced close to home, this is where you go.

Kitzie’s

Kitzie’s, with multiple locations across the Eastern Panhandle, brings the steakhouse experience to a casual, welcoming setting. Known for generous portions and perfectly cooked steaks, Kitzie’s pairs each cut with signature sides and classic sauces. Whether it’s a sizzling sirloin or a tender New York strip, every dish is cooked to order and served with the kind of hospitality that makes guests feel like family.

Final Cut Steakhouse

Located inside Hollywood Casino at Charles Town Races, Final Cut Steakhouse is where fine dining meets flawless execution. The restaurant features USDA prime cuts, dry-aged beef, and an award-winning wine list that makes it a true destination for steak lovers. Each dish is plated with elegance and precision, offering a taste of big-city dining right in the heart of Jefferson County. It’s indulgence done the right way.

Horst Meats Retail Market

Horst Meats in Hagerstown is the kind of family-run market that defines quality the old-fashioned way — with skilled butchers, premium cuts, and a reputation built on trust. Their steaks are consistently praised for their freshness and flavor, sourced and prepared with expertise honed over generations. Whether you’re planning a weeknight dinner or a weekend feast, Horst Meats makes sure your steak is the star of the table.

Thanks, ChatGPT.