The 5 Best Seafood Stores (Not Restaurant) Around Martinsburg

Seafood lovers in the Eastern Panhandle don’t need an oceanfront view to enjoy the day’s freshest catch. From live crabs and hand-cut fillets to homemade crab cakes and shrimp by the pound, Martinsburg’s top seafood markets bring the coast inland—one cooler at a time. Highlighted in this year’s Best of the Best contest, these local favorites have built their reputations on freshness, service, and a genuine love for good food.

Just In Time Seafood

Just In Time Seafood lives up to its name, offering the kind of freshness usually found dockside. This Martinsburg favorite is known for its rotating selection of crabs, shrimp, oysters, and fish sourced straight from the coast. Locals praise the store’s quality and consistency, as well as the friendly staff who are always ready with prep tips or cooking advice. From summer crab feasts to weeknight seafood dinners, Just In Time is the go-to spot for customers who care about flavor and freshness above all.

Johnnies Express

Johnnies Express may sound like a convenience stop, but its seafood counter is the real draw. Known for its variety and quality, Johnnies offers everything from fresh fish to locally prepared seafood salads. The store’s commitment to fast, friendly service makes it easy to grab what you need and get home to start cooking. It’s a perfect blend of convenience and craftsmanship—proof that great seafood doesn’t have to come with a long drive to the bay.

Les & Ali’s Jumbo Seafood

Les & Ali’s Jumbo Seafood has become a go-to for crab lovers across the region. Based in Halltown, the shop is famous for its generous portions, fair prices, and reliable quality. Customers come for blue crabs, shrimp, and fish, often cooked or cleaned to order. The friendly family-run operation keeps things simple and fresh, earning its loyal following one bushel at a time.

Potomac Seafood Market

Potomac Seafood Market in Hagerstown delivers the goods for serious seafood fans. Known for its wide selection and fair pricing, this market caters to everyone from restaurant owners to home chefs. Fresh fish, shellfish, and seasonal catches fill the cases, and customers often praise the cleanliness and expert service. For those willing to cross state lines for quality, Potomac Seafood Market is well worth the trip.

Tony’s Butcher Block

Tony’s Butcher Block in Berkeley Springs might be best known for its meats, but its seafood selection deserves equal attention. The market sources high-quality fish and shellfish, offering customers a reliable place to pick up salmon, shrimp, and other seafood staples without the long haul. Tony’s combination of expert butchery, customer service, and fresh product lines makes it a standout in every category it touches.

Thanks, ChatGPT.