The 5 Best Sandwiches Around Martinsburg

A great sandwich is all about balance — the perfect bread, the right fillings, and that unmistakable combination of texture and taste that makes every bite memorable. Martinsburg’s sandwich scene offers something for everyone, from smoky barbecue melts to creative café creations. The Best of the Best contest recognized local spots that have mastered the art of handheld perfection, proving that sometimes the simplest meals are the ones that hit hardest.

Toasted

Toasted has become synonymous with sandwich excellence in the Martinsburg area. With locations in both Hedgesville and Inwood, this locally owned favorite puts a gourmet spin on classic comfort food. Each sandwich — pressed to golden perfection — combines fresh ingredients, inventive flavors, and a touch of artistry. Whether it’s a gooey grilled cheese, a loaded breakfast melt, or something new from their ever-evolving menu, Toasted turns every meal into a craveable experience.

The Cider Press

The Cider Press Deli & Grill in Inwood brings farm-fresh flair to its hearty sandwiches. Known for creative pairings and generous portions, the restaurant’s menu features everything from juicy chicken melts to deli classics stacked high. Guests love the local ingredients and house-made sauces that make each bite unique. With a warm, rustic atmosphere and friendly service, The Cider Press feels both upscale and down-home all at once.

Titan BBQ

At Titan BBQ in Inwood, the sandwiches are smoky, messy, and unforgettable — just the way barbecue should be. From pulled pork and brisket to smoked chicken piled between fresh buns, every bite is packed with rich flavor. Titan’s slow-cooked meats and tangy house sauces give their sandwiches a backyard authenticity that keeps customers coming back. It’s comfort food, done with competition-level care.

Food By Fire

Food By Fire in Martinsburg lives up to its name, cooking everything — sandwiches included — over open flames for that signature wood-fired flavor. Their creations feature tender meats, melted cheese, and just enough char to make every sandwich stand out. Whether catering or serving from their food truck, the team at Food By Fire has mastered how to deliver smoke, heat, and heart in every bite.

Haulin Butts BBQ

Haulin Butts BBQ in Ranson proves that great sandwiches don’t need fancy frills — just incredible barbecue and passion behind the grill. Their pulled pork and brisket sandwiches are crowd favorites, loaded with tender, saucy meat and served up with a smile. Known for their mobile setup and community spirit, Haulin Butts keeps things fun, flavorful, and authentically West Virginia.

Thanks, ChatGPT.