The 5 Best Pizzas Around Martinsburg

A Slice Above: Martinsburg’s Favorite Pizza Spots

Whether thin and crispy or thick and chewy, pizza has a way of uniting everyone around the table. Martinsburg’s pizza scene blends tradition with creativity — from classic New York–style pies to wood-fired perfection and small-town favorites that taste like home. The Best of the Best contest highlighted the area’s top spots where each slice is crafted with care, fresh ingredients, and just the right amount of melted cheese magic.

King’s New York Pizza

With multiple locations across the region, King’s New York Pizza has become synonymous with authentic East Coast flavor. Their hand-tossed crust, zesty tomato sauce, and generous toppings have earned them a devoted following among pizza purists. Every pie is baked to perfection — thin, foldable, and fresh from the oven. Whether dining in or ordering to go, King’s delivers a true New York experience with a hometown twist.

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza in Martinsburg brings old-world flavor to modern dining. Each pizza is cooked in a traditional brick oven, giving it that signature crispy crust and smoky edge. The menu balances crowd-pleasing classics with specialty pies that highlight fresh ingredients and bold flavor combinations. From the moment the aroma hits the air, you know you’re in for something special — pizza that tastes like craftsmanship in every bite.

Middleway Market

Middleway Market in Kearneysville is proof that great pizza can come from unexpected places. What looks like a small-town convenience stop hides one of the area’s most loved pizzerias. Their pies are hearty, perfectly cooked, and made with a balance of flavor that keeps regulars coming back. It’s local, low-key, and everything you want in a hidden gem.

Food By Fire

Food By Fire in Martinsburg takes its name seriously — each pizza is kissed by real flames for a smoky, irresistible finish. Their wood-fired pies feature crisp crusts, fresh toppings, and creative combinations that go beyond the ordinary. Whether you prefer a margherita or a meaty masterpiece, the result is the same: rustic perfection that feels as comforting as it does elevated.

Mythical Pizza

Mythical Pizza in Berkeley Springs lives up to its name with imaginative flavors and out-of-the-box creations. The shop pairs classic techniques with playful twists, resulting in pies that are as fun to order as they are to eat. With locally inspired names and creative toppings, Mythical Pizza proves that great pizza doesn’t have to take itself too seriously — it just has to taste amazing.

Thanks, ChatGPT.