The 5 Best Pizza Shops Around Martinsburg

From a thin, foldable slice to a crispy flatbread fresh from the oven, pizza offers something for nearly every taste. Traditional cheese and pepperoni remain popular, while specialty toppings, different crust styles and distinctive cooking methods provide plenty of variety. Whether ordering dinner for the family or grabbing a quick meal at a food truck, pizza is a versatile favorite. The Best of the Best contest features pizzerias and mobile kitchens serving communities throughout the Eastern Panhandle.

King’s New York Pizza - Multiple Locations

New York-style pizza is the specialty at King’s New York Pizza, which operates multiple locations in Martinsburg. The restaurant prepares hand-stretched pizzas with the thin crust associated with traditional New York pies, along with additional crust styles and specialty selections. Customers can choose from established topping combinations or customize their orders to suit individual preferences. Dine-in, carryout and delivery options provide flexibility for families, commuters and other customers seeking a freshly prepared pizza for lunch or dinner.

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza

Brick-oven cooking gives the pizzas at Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza in Martinsburg their distinctive character. The independent Italian restaurant uses a stone-hearth baking method that produces a crisp crust and the lightly charred edges associated with high-temperature ovens. Its menu offers traditional and specialty pizzas, allowing customers to choose familiar flavors or explore different topping combinations. Additional Italian favorites round out the dining experience, making Angelo’s an option for customers seeking a casual meal centered on freshly baked pizza.

F'N Flatbreads

Artisan flatbread pizzas and mobile food service are the focus at F'N Flatbreads, a veteran-owned food trailer based in the Martinsburg area. The business prepares personal-sized flatbreads with a variety of sauces, cheeses, vegetables and other toppings. Its mobile kitchen brings freshly prepared food to community gatherings, breweries and outdoor events throughout Berkeley County. The individual portions and flatbread format provide an alternative to traditional pizzeria offerings, giving customers a convenient way to enjoy pizza-inspired dishes while attending local activities.

Food By Fire

Wood-fired cooking is central to Food By Fire, a Martinsburg-based mobile kitchen and catering business. The operation prepares artisan pizzas using high-temperature cooking methods that produce crisp crusts and distinctive fire-baked flavors. Its mobile setup allows freshly prepared food to be served at community events, private celebrations and catered gatherings. By combining pizza preparation with its broader emphasis on fire-based cooking, Food By Fire brings an alternative to conventional restaurant pizza service to locations throughout the Eastern Panhandle.

Mythical Pizza

Family-friendly dining and a variety of pizza selections are part of the experience at Mythical Pizza in Berkeley Springs. The pizzeria serves traditional hand-tossed pizzas alongside specialty combinations, with additional Italian-inspired menu choices available. Gluten-free crust options accommodate customers seeking alternatives to conventional pizza dough. Carryout service and casual dining room seating provide flexibility for families and individuals, whether picking up dinner or enjoying a meal at the restaurant. Its assortment of pizza styles offers choices for different tastes and occasions.

Created or enhanced with ChatGPT.