The 5 Best Overall Restaurants Around Martinsburg

From family dinners to special celebrations and everything in between, the best restaurants offer more than just food—they create a vibe, a memory, and a reason to come back. The Best of the Best voters in Martinsburg and the surrounding areas knew exactly where to go when casting their ballots for overall restaurant favorites. The following spots combine atmosphere, service, and flavor to rise above the rest.

Kitzie’s

With multiple locations and a menu that hits every note from steaks to seafood to homemade desserts, Kitzie’s isn’t just a place to eat—it’s a place to linger over good conversation and great food. Signature dishes like their crab-stuffed flounder and creamy pastas have earned loyal fans, while daily specials keep the experience fresh.

Thai Martinsburg

For those craving bold flavors and artful presentation, Thai Martinsburg delivers. The cozy downtown setting sets the stage for fragrant curries, flavorful noodle dishes, and crisp spring rolls that keep customers coming back. It's no surprise that this spot continues to impress, from its attentive service to its consistently high-quality dishes.

Toasted

Toasted’s laid-back style, creative sandwiches, and craft beers have made it a beloved hangout in Inwood. Whether you're in the mood for a burger topped with pork belly or a chicken sandwich with house-made slaw, their elevated comfort food menu hits the mark. Add friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, and you've got a formula that wins hearts (and votes).

The Cider Press

Known for its fresh ingredients and upscale take on deli classics, The Cider Press blends small-town charm with big-city flavor. Diners rave about their signature applewood-smoked dishes and craft cocktails, served in a cozy, rustic setting that’s perfect for brunch, lunch, or date night.

The Girls Joint

Just across the Maryland line in Williamsport, The Girls Joint offers a rotating menu of comfort food favorites with a healthy twist. Locals appreciate the fresh ingredients, generous portions, and fun atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where everything feels made with love—and it shows.

Thanks, ChatGPT.