The 5 Best Menus Around Martinsburg

It’s not just about what’s on the plate—it’s how many ways a restaurant can surprise and satisfy with every visit. The most beloved menus in the Martinsburg area don’t just offer variety; they serve personality, creativity, and crave-worthy combinations that reflect local tastes. In this year’s Best of the Best contest, these five dining destinations earned high praise for putting together menus that make ordering a challenge—in the best way.

Kitzie’s

Kitzie’s caters to comfort food lovers, picky eaters, and culinary explorers alike. With a robust lineup that spans house-smoked meats, pasta dishes, salads, burgers, and a full bar menu, Kitzie’s has become a Martinsburg institution. Daily specials and seasonal updates keep things fresh, while reliable favorites ensure everyone leaves full and happy.

Titan BBQ

Titan BBQ brings big flavor and bold choices to Inwood’s dining scene. From smoked brisket to St. Louis-style ribs and loaded mac-and-cheese, the menu delivers classic barbecue with a few creative twists. This is the kind of place where your biggest challenge isn’t finding something good—it’s choosing just one thing. A favorite among carnivores and comfort-food fans.

Toasted

Toasted may be known for sandwiches, but the full menu reads like a comfort food dream. With loaded grilled cheeses, melt-in-your-mouth fries, sweet treats, and seasonal surprises, this Hedgesville hotspot doesn’t just play it safe. It pushes the boundaries of fast-casual in all the right ways, and the results are delicious. Even the sides get rave reviews.

Food By Fire

Food By Fire delivers wood-fired perfection with a menu that’s smoked to order and built to impress. From barbecue plates to scratch-made sides and rotating specials, this Martinsburg favorite has developed a following for its flavorful consistency and smoky soul. It’s an ideal choice for anyone who wants a short menu done exceptionally well.

TJ’s Pit Stop

TJ’s Pit Stop in Charles Town might fly under the radar, but regulars know this is a local gem. Its menu is loaded with homestyle eats—burgers, sandwiches, daily specials—that hit the spot without breaking the bank. It’s that go-to spot where the staff knows your name and the menu never lets you down.

Thanks, ChatGPT.