The 5 Best Italian Food Restaurants Around Martinsburg

Italian cuisine holds a beloved place in the hearts of Martinsburg's food enthusiasts, celebrated for its bold flavors, comforting dishes, and rich culinary traditions. From artisan pizzas to classic pastas and modern interpretations, the area's Italian restaurants offer authentic experiences that transport diners straight to Italy. Each year, The Journal's Best of the Best contest spotlights the top Italian eateries, chosen by locals for their outstanding food, atmosphere, and service.

King’s New York Pizza

Crowned the winner, King’s New York Pizza is a local favorite, renowned for its traditional New York-style pizzas and a wide array of Italian classics. With multiple locations in Martinsburg, King’s offers a consistently delightful dining experience, characterized by their use of fresh ingredients and homemade sauces, drawing regulars and new visitors alike.

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza

A finalist, Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza provides a cozy atmosphere where guests can enjoy a variety of handcrafted pizzas cooked to perfection in a traditional brick oven. Their commitment to authenticity is evident in every slice, featuring a perfect blend of crispy crusts, savory sauces, and fresh toppings.

La Mezzaluna Café

Also among the finalists, La Mezzaluna Café in Charles Town is celebrated for its intimate dining setting and exceptional Italian fare. The café offers a menu rich with flavorsome pastas, risottos, and specialty dishes, all prepared with meticulous attention to detail and a passion for Italian cooking.

Philly Cheese Steak Plus

Included in the top 5, Philly Cheese Steak Plus may surprise with its name, but it stands out for its Italian offerings as well. Located in Hedgesville, this eatery blends American classics with Italian favorites, providing a unique twist on traditional recipes and a casual dining experience beloved by locals.

Violino Ristorante Italiano

Rounding out the top 5, Violino Ristorante Italiano in Winchester offers a fine dining experience with a focus on Northern Italian cuisine. The restaurant is known for its elegant setting, extensive wine list, and a menu that features both classic dishes and innovative creations, all prepared with the finest ingredients.

Thanks, ChatGPT.

Photo: Angelo's Brick Oven Pizza