The 5 Best Italian Eateries Around Martinsburg

Italian cuisine offers something for nearly every appetite, from hand-tossed pizzas and hearty pasta dishes to savory sauces and traditional family recipes. Whether enjoying a leisurely dinner or picking up a quick meal, diners can find plenty of familiar favorites at Italian restaurants throughout the Eastern Panhandle. The Best of the Best contest features establishments that bring these comforting flavors to local tables through both traditional preparations and casual pizzeria dining.

King’s New York Pizza - Multiple Locations

New York-style pizza and classic Italian comfort food are the specialties at King’s New York Pizza, which operates multiple locations in Martinsburg. The restaurant serves hand-tossed pizzas, calzones and strombolis alongside pasta favorites such as baked ziti, fettuccine Alfredo and chicken parmigiana. Specialty hot subs provide additional choices for customers seeking a convenient meal. With generous portions, casual dining rooms, carryout and local delivery options, King’s accommodates everything from family dinners to quick lunches.

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza

Brick-oven cooking gives the pizzas at Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza in Martinsburg their distinctive character. The independent pizzeria prepares classic margherita pizzas, gourmet specialty pies and stuffed-crust options, along with calzones and strombolis. Garlic knots, Italian pasta dishes, chicken wings and fresh salads round out the menu, providing choices beyond traditional pizza. Its combination of brick-oven specialties and familiar Italian-American favorites offers options for casual lunches, family meals and pizza nights.

La Mezzaluna Café

Traditional Italian recipes and an intimate dining atmosphere distinguish La Mezzaluna Café in Charles Town. The restaurant prepares specialties such as veal marsala, chicken francese, eggplant parmigiana and shrimp fra diavolo, along with baked pasta dishes and gourmet paninis. A selection of Italian wines complements the menu, while traditional desserts provide a fitting conclusion to the meal. Its combination of carefully prepared entrees and full-service dining makes La Mezzaluna Café an option for both everyday meals and special occasions.

King's New York Pizza

Hand-stretched New York-style pizza and Italian-American favorites are central to the menu at King's New York Pizza in Falling Waters. The restaurant offers traditional thin-crust pizzas, Sicilian deep-dish pies, oven-baked subs and pasta entrees, along with a selection of appetizers. Customers can choose from different pizza styles or enjoy a complete Italian-inspired meal. Online ordering and carryout service add convenience for busy families and commuters seeking familiar favorites without a lengthy dining experience.

Mythical Pizza

Pizza and hearty Italian comfort food bring families and friends together at Mythical Pizza in Berkeley Springs. The restaurant serves hand-tossed pizzas, baked calzones, oversized strombolis and pasta dishes, along with toasted Italian subs. Its menu provides a variety of choices for diners interested in traditional pizzeria favorites or a more substantial meal. With casual sit-down dining and convenient carryout options, Mythical Pizza accommodates relaxed family dinners and meals on the go.

Created or enhanced with ChatGPT.