The 5 Best Italian Cusines Around Martinsburg

Italian food has a way of making every meal feel like a celebration—whether it’s a bubbling lasagna, a perfectly tossed Caesar, or a slice of pizza straight from a stone oven. In the Martinsburg area, Italian restaurants bring together generations of tradition and modern flair, crafting dishes that warm the heart as much as they fill the plate. This year’s Best of the Best contest honored local favorites that go beyond red sauce to serve up flavor, family atmosphere, and full stomachs.

King’s New York Pizza – Martinsburg

King’s New York Pizza is a household name for Italian food in the Eastern Panhandle—and for good reason. With its flagship location in Martinsburg and several others throughout the region, King’s serves up classic New York-style pizza, hearty pasta dishes, and subs that pull no punches in portion or flavor. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, while the menu covers all the Italian-American favorites from baked ziti to veal parm. It's a reliable go-to whether you're grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a full meal.

Angelo’s Brick Oven Pizza

Angelo’s brings old-world charm to Martinsburg with its hand-tossed, brick oven pizzas and rustic Italian comfort food. The crust has just the right amount of char, the sauce is rich but balanced, and the toppings are fresh and generously applied. Beyond the pies, the pasta dishes, garlic knots, and house specialties round out a menu that’s simple, satisfying, and deeply rooted in tradition. It’s the kind of place that turns pizza night into something special.

La Mezzaluna Café

Tucked into Charles Town, La Mezzaluna Café offers an intimate, upscale take on Italian dining. From homemade sauces to carefully plated entrées, the menu reflects a clear dedication to authenticity and detail. Guests can enjoy staples like chicken marsala, fettuccine alfredo, and shrimp scampi, all served in a setting that feels both cozy and refined. Whether you're out for a romantic dinner or celebrating with family, La Mezzaluna sets the tone for a memorable evening.

King’s New York Pizza – Falling Waters

The Falling Waters location of King’s New York Pizza keeps the brand’s high standards alive and well. The menu mirrors the Martinsburg original, offering everything from stuffed shells to sausage rolls and crowd-pleasing calzones. With fast service, a laid-back dining room, and flavors that never miss, it’s a favorite for both locals and travelers passing through. Consistency is king here—and so is the garlic bread.

Mythical Pizza

Mythical Pizza in Berkeley Springs adds a creative twist to the Italian dining scene. With cleverly named pies like “The Cyclops” and “Centaur Supreme,” the menu offers both classic combinations and adventurous flavors. While the atmosphere leans casual and fun, the kitchen doesn’t play around—ingredients are fresh, crusts are crisp, and sauces are house-made. It’s the kind of spot where kids marvel at the names, and adults keep coming back for the taste.

Thanks, ChatGPT.