The 5 Best Insurance Agencies Around Martinsburg

The right insurance agency does more than write policies — it provides peace of mind. Whether protecting homes, vehicles, or livelihoods, these professionals help clients plan for the unexpected with confidence and care. The Best of the Best contest honors these agencies across the Eastern Panhandle known for their expertise, reliability, and exceptional customer service.

Smallwood & Small Insurance

Smallwood & Small Insurance in Martinsburg has been a trusted name in coverage for generations. As an independent agency, they represent multiple carriers, allowing them to tailor policies that truly fit each client’s needs. Their experienced team specializes in personal, commercial, and life insurance solutions, always delivered with integrity and attention to detail. Local families and businesses alike rely on Smallwood & Small for guidance that’s as personal as it is professional.

Eric Gates – State Farm Insurance Agent

Eric Gates and his team at State Farm in Martinsburg are known for their friendly service and thorough understanding of client needs. They offer a full suite of insurance options, including auto, home, renters, and life coverage, all backed by clear explanations and genuine care. The office’s welcoming atmosphere and dedication to helping customers feel confident in their coverage make them a standout in the community.

Kay Lewis – State Farm Insurance Agency

Kay Lewis’s State Farm agency brings a personalized, community-driven touch to insurance services. Located in Martinsburg, her office offers coverage for every stage of life, from first cars to family homes and business ventures. Known for her professionalism and compassion, Kay and her staff go above and beyond to ensure every client feels protected and informed.

Amanda Kaplan – State Farm Insurance Agent

Amanda Kaplan’s State Farm office in Williamsport delivers dependable service with a personal touch. Her team emphasizes education and accessibility, helping clients understand their options and make informed decisions. With a focus on community relationships and customer care, Kaplan’s agency stands out as a trusted partner for Maryland and West Virginia residents alike.

Dawn Newland – State Farm Insurance Agent

Dawn Newland’s State Farm office in Martinsburg combines local expertise with national support. Her team provides coverage that fits real lives — from auto and home to business and life insurance. Clients value their responsiveness and personal attention, as well as the peace of mind that comes from working with a team that truly listens.

Thanks, ChatGPT.