The 5 Best Fine Dining Restaurants Around Martinsburg

Fine dining isn’t just about white tablecloths and prix fixe menus—it’s about attention to detail, locally inspired ingredients, and the kind of ambiance that makes a meal feel like an experience. In the Martinsburg area, high-end restaurants are proving that sophistication doesn’t require a big city zip code. This year’s Best of the Best contest showcased restaurants where culinary artistry meets top-tier hospitality—ideal for date nights, special occasions, or anytime you want more than just dinner.

Kitzie’s

While Kitzie’s is known for its approachable vibe, its execution puts it firmly in the fine dining conversation. With multiple locations, including its flagship on Rock Cliff Drive, the restaurant combines elevated American fare with an atmosphere that’s polished yet inviting. Steaks, seafood, and house-made pastas headline a menu that balances tradition and flair. Whether you're there for a business dinner or a quiet celebration, the attentive service and refined plating make each visit feel like an occasion.

Bavarian Inn

Perched above the Potomac River in Shepherdstown, the Bavarian Inn blends European elegance with Appalachian charm. Known for its fine continental cuisine, the restaurant offers everything from schnitzel and spaetzle to filet mignon and house-crafted desserts. White linens, a deep wine list, and scenic views round out an experience that feels like a retreat. Whether dining indoors or overlooking the bluffs, it’s a landmark that delivers fine dining with Old World gravitas.

Brix 27

Downtown Martinsburg’s Brix 27 elevates dining with a contemporary menu rooted in seasonal flavors and wine-forward pairings. With an upscale bistro feel, the space is equally suited to intimate dinners and celebratory outings. The kitchen blends modern techniques with comforting dishes, while the wine cellar and tasting events offer added appeal for those who like their entrées with a curated pour. It’s a culinary escape without leaving city limits.

La Mezzaluna Café

La Mezzaluna Café in Charles Town offers classic Italian fare with an upscale twist. Candlelit tables, rich sauces, and expertly crafted pasta dishes transport diners to southern Europe without the airfare. With a menu that features veal, seafood, and fresh mozzarella prepared in-house, the café offers fine dining with the warmth of a family-owned kitchen. It’s a place where the food speaks softly—and leaves a lasting impression.

The Sycamore at Stonebridge

Located on the Stonebridge Golf Course, The Sycamore offers refined dining in a relaxed, scenic setting. The menu emphasizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients, and the kitchen leans into creative takes on upscale American cuisine. From seared scallops to pork belly starters, each plate is carefully composed. With views of the greens and a dining room that balances rustic charm with elegance, it’s a spot where fine dining feels unforced but undeniably polished.

Thanks, ChatGPT.