The 5 Best Diamond Dealers Around Martinsburg

Diamonds may be timeless, but the jewelers who shape, sell, and celebrate them bring their own sparkle to the story. Across the Eastern Panhandle, local diamond dealers blend artistry with expertise — helping customers find pieces that symbolize life’s biggest moments. From family-owned jewelers to national names, these businesses shine for their integrity, craftsmanship, and ability to turn every purchase into a personal connection. The Best of the Best contest recognized the region’s brightest gems in more ways than one.

Bechdel Jewelers

Bechdel Jewelers in Inwood has been a trusted name in fine jewelry for generations, now proudly partnered with Nelson Coleman Jewelers. The store offers an exquisite selection of diamonds, engagement rings, and custom designs, combining traditional values with modern style. Customers return for the knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and personalized service that make every visit special. Whether celebrating a milestone or creating a new heirloom, Bechdel Jewelers helps every piece tell its own story of love and legacy.

Feagans Jewelers Inc.

Since 1945, Feagans Jewelers in Charles Town has been synonymous with sparkle. Family-owned and operated, the shop specializes in diamonds, gemstones, and fine jewelry repair. Their team’s attention to detail and commitment to quality have earned them generations of loyal customers. At Feagans, choosing a diamond isn’t just a transaction — it’s a tradition steeped in trust, craftsmanship, and care.

LA Roberts Jewelers

Located in historic downtown Martinsburg, LA Roberts Jewelers has been turning moments into memories for decades. The full-service jeweler carries a stunning array of diamond rings, watches, and custom pieces designed to suit every style. Known for its expert jewelers and warm customer service, the shop makes every client feel like part of the family. Whether restoring a family treasure or selecting a new symbol of love, LA Roberts always delivers brilliance.

Christian Caine Design

Christian Caine Design bridges Old World artistry with modern luxury. With locations across the region, including Martinsburg, the jeweler is celebrated for custom designs inspired by European elegance. Every diamond and setting reflects a designer’s eye for detail and a craftsman’s touch for perfection. For clients seeking something beyond the ordinary, Christian Caine transforms imagination into wearable art — one bespoke piece at a time.

Kay Jewelers of Martinsburg

A household name in fine jewelry, Kay Jewelers continues to shine in Martinsburg with its trusted service and dazzling selection. The store offers everything from engagement rings and wedding bands to fashion jewelry and timepieces. Backed by national recognition and local charm, Kay Jewelers combines reliability with romance, helping customers celebrate milestones with confidence — and just the right amount of sparkle.

Thanks, ChatGPT.