The 5 Best Dessert Menus Around Martinsburg

Dessert isn't just a dish—it's a destination. Whether it's layered, frozen, fried, or drizzled, a great dessert menu adds the final punctuation mark to any meal. And in the Martinsburg area, that punctuation often comes with sprinkles, whipped cream, or a graham cracker crust. As revealed in this year’s Best of the Best contest, locals know exactly where to go when the sweet tooth strikes. From rich cheesecakes to silky custards and classic soft serve, these top spots prove that dessert is serious business.

Everything Cheesecake

Everything Cheesecake lives up to its name—and then some. Located on Winchester Avenue in Martinsburg, this small shop has earned a big reputation for its wide variety of homemade cheesecakes, available by the slice or whole. Rotating flavors include classics like New York-style and strawberry swirl, along with decadent creations like turtle, lemon blueberry, and peanut butter cup. With each dessert made from scratch, it's no wonder locals treat this place as the final stop for every celebration—or random Tuesday.

Jules Frozen Custard

Over in Inwood, Jules Frozen Custard brings creamy Midwest-style indulgence to the Eastern Panhandle. Known for its ultra-smooth texture and rotating flavors, the custard is served in cones, sundaes, shakes, and specialty treats. The menu includes a variety of mix-ins and toppings, making it as customizable as it is delicious. With outdoor seating and a laid-back vibe, Jules is the kind of spot that turns one scoop into a weekly tradition.

Sweet P’s Son Of A Cheesecake

Equal parts charm and indulgence, Sweet P’s Son Of A Cheesecake in Inwood delivers cheesecake with personality. Offering slices stacked high and loaded with flavor, this dessert shop thrives on creativity. Flavors are bold and unapologetic—think banana pudding, key lime, and cookie overload—all served in a cozy, casual setting. It’s a hidden gem that’s anything but shy when it comes to serving up something sweet.

Mr. Richard's Hot Dogs and Soft Serve Ice Cream

Don’t let the hot dogs in the name fool you—Mr. Richard’s in Inwood is also a destination for soft serve lovers. This local favorite dishes up creamy cones, sundaes, and shakes that keep families coming back all summer long. The retro-style setup and friendly service give it an old-school feel, while the dessert menu stays fresh with classic flavors and fun toppings. It’s a roadside stop that delivers on nostalgia and taste.

Tad's Dairy Barn

Tad’s Dairy Barn in Martinsburg is a seasonal staple that has been satisfying sweet cravings for years. Offering soft serve, milkshakes, and frozen favorites in a no-frills setting, Tad’s delivers dessert with a smile—and often a line out the door. It's the kind of place where kids and grown-ups alike find something they love, whether it’s a dipped cone or a sundae topped with house-made sauce. Simple, classic, and beloved.

Thanks, ChatGPT.