The 5 Best Cakes / Cupcakes Around Martinsburg

A good cake marks a celebration — but a great one can turn an ordinary day into something sweetly memorable. From towering cheesecakes to cupcakes topped with artistic flair, Martinsburg’s bakers know that dessert is both an indulgence and an expression of love. The Best of the Best contest highlighted the area’s standout shops where frosting meets creativity and every bite tastes like happiness made fresh.

Everything Cheesecake

Everything Cheesecake has become Martinsburg’s go-to spot for rich, unforgettable desserts. While the name says “cheesecake,” this bakery goes beyond the basics with layered cakes and indulgent cupcakes that rival their signature slices. Customers rave about the variety — from strawberry crunch to banana pudding — and the personal service that makes each order feel special. It’s more than dessert; it’s a community favorite built on passion and flavor.

Sweet P’s Son of a Cheesecake

Sweet P’s Son of a Cheesecake in Inwood is a dessert lover’s dream with its creative, ever-changing lineup of flavors. Known for its rich cheesecakes and decadent cupcakes, Sweet P’s blends traditional recipes with inventive twists that keep fans coming back for more. Whether it’s a slice of peanut butter perfection or a custom cake for a special occasion, Sweet P’s proves that baking is both art and adventure.

Truffle Queen

The Truffle Queen in Inwood brings elegance to every confection she makes. While her name is synonymous with hand-crafted truffles, her cakes and cupcakes have earned just as much local love. Beautifully designed and perfectly portioned, her creations showcase both taste and technique. It’s boutique baking with a personal touch — the kind of quality that makes small-batch desserts feel like royal treatment.

Guilty Pleasures, LLC

Guilty Pleasures, LLC in Elkins serves up the kind of desserts that make moderation optional. Known for lavish cakes and filled cupcakes, this bakery’s creations are designed to impress both the eye and the taste buds. Each item feels handcrafted with care, from smooth buttercream finishes to imaginative flavor combinations. It’s the perfect name for a place that makes indulgence feel entirely justified.

Two Moms’ and a Cupcake

Two Moms’ and a Cupcake in Harpers Ferry proves that family and frosting are a winning combination. This charming bakery specializes in cupcakes that balance light, fluffy textures with bold, satisfying flavor. Their colorful designs and seasonal specialties make them a favorite for birthdays and events — or simply as a sweet pick-me-up after a long day. Every batch reflects the heart behind the name: baked with love, shared with joy.

Thanks, ChatGPT.