The 5 Best Bakeries Around Martinsburg

The scent of sugar, butter, and nostalgia drifts through Martinsburg’s bakery scene, where every display case tells a story of community and craft. From rich cheesecakes to farm-fresh pies and cupcakes baked with love, local bakers are serving up comfort one slice at a time. The Best of the Best contest celebrated the area’s top spots for pastries, desserts, and smiles — reminding everyone that life’s milestones, big or small, deserve something sweet.

Everything Cheesecake

Everything Cheesecake is proof that dessert can be both decadent and down-to-earth. This Martinsburg favorite has earned a loyal following for its inventive spins on a classic treat — from traditional New York-style slices to bold flavors like strawberry crunch, banana pudding, and Oreo dream. Each creation is made from scratch, and the staff’s friendly energy adds to the charm. Whether you’re celebrating or just craving something indulgent, Everything Cheesecake delivers a perfect balance of rich flavor and local flair.

Orr’s Farm Market

Orr’s Farm Market isn’t just about produce — it’s also home to one of Martinsburg’s most beloved bakeries. Their pies, cookies, and seasonal sweets showcase the farm’s own fresh ingredients, from apple-filled crusts to berry-packed muffins. Everything is baked with a homespun touch that reflects generations of family tradition. For locals, a stop at Orr’s means leaving with more than groceries; it means taking home a taste of the season itself.

Sweet P’s Son of a Cheesecake

Sweet P’s Son of a Cheesecake in Inwood brings creativity to the cheesecake game with a rotating menu of flavors that range from classic to wildly inventive. The small-batch bakery thrives on variety — think peanut butter, key lime, and red velvet cheesecakes, all served with a personal touch. The playful name says it all: Sweet P’s is about having fun with flavor and making every visit feel like dessert discovery day.

Truffle Queen

The Truffle Queen in Inwood is exactly what her name implies — a master of bite-sized luxury. Known for hand-rolled chocolate truffles and gift-ready confections, she brings artistry to every batch. Her Facebook followers rave about seasonal offerings and creative flavor combinations that make even a small treat feel special. It’s local decadence at its finest, crafted with both passion and precision.

Two Moms’ and a Cupcake

Two Moms’ and a Cupcake in Harpers Ferry bakes up sweetness with a side of heart. The family-run shop is loved for its moist cupcakes, buttercream frosting, and whimsical designs that make celebrations extra memorable. From classic vanilla to salted caramel and everything in between, their treats prove that simple ingredients, done well, can turn an ordinary day into a reason to celebrate.

Thanks, ChatGPT.